Skip to Main Content Skip to Footer Content

Drywall Repair and Plaster Repair in Miller Place, NY

Drywall and Plaster Repair Professionals You Can Trust

If your walls are showing cracks, dents, or water damage, you don’t have to live with imperfections. At Five Star Painting of Port Jefferson, we provide expert plaster and drywall repair services in Miller Place, NY, restoring your walls so they look as smooth and flawless as the day they were built. Whether you’re dealing with minor blemishes or major repairs, our team has the tools, training, and attention to detail to handle it all.

Homeowners take pride in their homes, and you deserve walls that reflect that pride. That’s where we come in. Our team delivers not just quality repairs but also a clean, hassle-free experience. With professional craftsmanship, upfront pricing, and a focus on customer satisfaction, we make wall repair simple and stress-free.

When you choose us, you’re not just hiring drywall experts—you’re gaining trusted neighbors who understand what it takes to keep homes beautiful. Book a service!

Complete Drywall and Plaster Repair Services

From hairline cracks to water-damaged panels, we provide cost-effective solutions that blend seamlessly with your existing walls. We work with all drywall types—including Sheetrock, gypsum board, cement board, and green board—and finish with professional painting services for results that truly last.

Our Drywall Repair Process and Finish Levels

We offer a range of finishing levels to ensure your repaired surface perfectly matches your home's needs and your desired outcome.

  • Level 0 - Unfinished: This basic, unfinished surface is ideal for hidden areas like closets or for surfaces that will be covered with tile or stonework.
  • Level 2 - Minimal Finishing: This option provides a basic finish, perfect for garages, basements, or laundry rooms where a simple, clean look is all you need.
  • Level 4 - Smooth Finish: The industry standard for most living spaces. This finish provides a smooth, ready-to-paint surface with minimal imperfections.
  • Level 5 - Ultra-Smooth Finish: The ultimate choice for a flawless, high-end look. This finish is perfect for rooms with bold lighting that might otherwise highlight imperfections.

A Painting Experience That Exceeds Expectations

Choosing the right painting company makes all the difference. Our customers consistently highlight our professionalism, reliability, and passion for delivering exceptional painting results. From transforming outdated kitchens to brightening entire homes, our team goes above and beyond to ensure every project is stress-free and beautifully finished.

Here’s why your neighbors recommend us:

  • Passionate Leadership: Owner Matt takes the time to explain the process, recommend colors, and ensure every detail is covered.
  • Professional & Reliable Team: Always punctual, respectful, and dedicated to keeping your space clean.
  • Creative Problem-Solving: We offer smart solutions and even connect you with trusted associates for work beyond our scope.
  • Quality That Lasts: From drywall repair to cabinet refinishing, our craftsmanship transforms spaces and saves homeowners money.
  • Fair & Honest Pricing: Transparent estimates with no hidden surprises.
  • Local Reputation: From clubhouses to condos, families and businesses in the area call on us again and again.

Don’t let cracks, dents, or water damage take away from the beauty of your home. Trust us for reliable plaster and drywall repair in Miller Place. NY. Schedule online!

  • Passionate Leadership: Owner Matt takes the time to explain the process, recommend colors, and ensure every detail is covered.

  • Professional & Reliable Team: Always punctual, respectful, and dedicated to keeping your space clean.

  • Creative Problem-Solving: We offer smart solutions and even connect you with trusted associates for work beyond our scope.

  • Quality That Lasts: From drywall repair to cabinet refinishing, our craftsmanship transforms spaces and saves homeowners money.

  • Fair & Honest Pricing: Transparent estimates with no hidden surprises.

  • Local Reputation: From clubhouses to condos, families and businesses in the area call on us again and again.

Thinking About Painting?

For your peace of mind, we also offer a warranty. Specifically, our residential and commercial painting services are warranted for 2 years. With us, your paint job isn't done until it's done right. Visit our warranty page to learn more.

Service You Can Trust!

Let us know how we can help you today.

Customer Reviews

View All Reviews
  • Blue star quote icon.

    Would give more stars if possible! Five Star completed full exterior and interior painting of our home. Fair pricing, timely in every aspect... communication and arrival times, color expert to help choose your perfect colors, meticulous neatness, extremely respectful of home, amazing work, and everyone was a pleasure to work with. I have pictures but they just don't do the work justice. Highly recommend without reservation.

    Maria G.
    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
  • Blue star quote icon.

    Used them for the first time, very happy! The person who gave us a quote was very thorough. They painted our deck in September and did a perfect job plus showed respect for our property. I like the way a project manager came the day before, we met with him and the painting team and then he came back after the job was done to inspect it and make sure we were fully satisfied before paying. In January they came and did interior painting and I was also great! There was a few areas in the bathroom we needed touched up and the project manager came the next day and took care of it for us. I’ve been very happy with the whole process and recommend them highly!

    Luanne K.
    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
  • Blue star quote icon.

    Five star painting did two colors on the entire exterior of my house. Not only Did they do an exemplary job of painting, but they were very careful with our sidewalks plants and borders. They showed up on Time every day, and worked diligently, efficiently, and quietly. My wife and I would recommend them for any of your painting needs.

    Paul R.
    ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Services may vary by location. For more information, including the most accurate list of services and guidance, contact your locally owned and operated Five Star Painting for details and a customized on-site assessment.

  • You can rest assured that our painters are skilled, knowledgeable, and respectful.

  • Our production managers ensure a smooth, efficient process, keeping everything on track.

  • We will only leave beautifully finished surfaces behind, and nothing else!

  • Our local experts always arrive on time and stay on budget.

Painting professional painting the exterior of a home.

Helpful Resources

We’re dedicated to helping home and business owners with their painting and refinishing projects. That’s why we’ve collected an array of helpful resources to answer questions and provide inspiration and tips. Keep reading and reach out to our team for more support!

  • Thermostat.

    When Is It Too Cold to Paint The Exterior of Your House? (And Ideal Conditions)

    Knowing the right temperature range for painting the exterior of your house is critical. If you start your project in temps outside this range, you risk premature paint failure and a tragic waste of time and money.

    Learn More
  • Paint buckets.

    How Long Can You Keep Paint Before It Goes Bad?

    We’ve all been there—a painting project doesn’t use up all the paint you bought, and now it’s time to hammer the lid back on and take it to the garage or basement storage area. That paint will go bad in two to fifteen years. That’s such a big range, so how do you determine when it’ll be spent? Examine the type of paint and storage conditions to estimate shelf life. We’ll walk you through it.  

    Learn More
  • Cleaning cabinets.

    How to Clean Your Painted Kitchen Cabinets

    Cleaning painted cabinets isn't just about wiping last night’s sauce splatter off. It's about removing the buildup that settles over time that stems from cooking, baking, and everyday handling of your painted kitchen cabinets. Safely removing this buildup can become more difficult, especially when harsher cleaning materials can damage the paint on your cabinets.

    Learn More
Service You Can Trust!

Let us know how we can help you today.

Drywall Repair Frequently Asked Questions

  • Our professionals are equipped to handle a wide range of issues, including:

    • Holes: From small dings to large holes caused by accidents or plumbing work, we have the techniques to patch and repair any size hole seamlessly.
    • Cracks: Whether caused by settling foundations or stress, we repair cracks with precision using joint tape and mud to prevent them from reappearing.
    • Water Damage: We assess the damage and, if necessary, replace affected sections of drywall or plaster to prevent further issues and restore the wall's integrity.
    • Minor Imperfections: We can address bumps, blemishes, and uneven textures to create a perfectly smooth, paint-ready surface.
Service You Can Trust!

Let us know how we can help you today.

Join Our Team

At Five Star Painting, we value the people who bring our exceptional paint jobs to life. Join our supportive team, where we not only take great care of our customers' homes but also prioritize our employees' well-being. We offer a stable career path with opportunities for growth. Discover what it means to be part of the Five Star Painting family!

Start your career with us today. We offer exciting opportunities for growth and success in an important space.
View All Open Positions